A recent teardown conducted by iFixit of the new Apple HomeView showed that Apple made design decisions that make repairing the device "unjustifiably difficult." According to the report, the device represents a step backward in repairability standards compared to the previous HomePod, as attempts to access internal components resulted in damage to some of them.
Internal and Thermal Design Challenges
The iFixit team faced technical difficulties from the start; the HomeView display is held in place using strong adhesives that make its removal a complicated process. Accessing the internal components also requires a variety of tools due to the use of a combination of Phillips and Torx screws in various sizes to secure internal parts.
Structurally, the speakers occupy most of the internal space behind the display, while the logic board is situated directly behind them. Apple designed the logic board so that its shield contacts the outer aluminum chassis to act as a heat sink to improve thermal performance, but the use of thermal paste and adhesives to secure this shield made removing the logic board an extremely difficult task.
Incompatibility Between Device Versions
The report also revealed a fundamental design difference between the different models; internal components of the wall-mounted version and the tabletop version turned out not to be interchangeable. Each version has a different internal design; the wall-mounted version uses a larger logic board, while the tabletop version relies on larger speakers and a base equipped with a pivot mount.
Despite these difficulties, the report found some replaceable parts, such as the USB-C port located in the base, as well as the passive speakers inside the chassis, which are designed similarly to the base of the HomePod, making them easier to disassemble.
What Does This Mean for Users?
This design direction raises serious questions about the sustainability of Apple's new devices. Because of the way the device is assembled, the display cannot be separated from the base without entering from the display side itself, which is fraught with risk. Furthermore, the reliance on heavy adhesive—such as the thick adhesive securing the speakers, which caused one of them to break during disassembly—means that the cost of repair or the likelihood of damaging components during an attempt could make it very difficult for users or technicians to repair the device, potentially driving them to replace it entirely rather than servicing it.