Opinions and Analysis

A Digital Twin Speaking in My Name: The Synthesia Experiment Raises Questions About Trust in Media

A TechCrunch journalist tried creating an interactive digital version of herself through Synthesia, trained on a single story and able to answer questions through voice and video. The experiment reveals the potential of digital twins, but raises deeper questions about trust and the limits of their use in journalism and institutional work.

2026-09-26
4 min read
258 views
certi.news Editorial Team
A Digital Twin Speaking in My Name: The Synthesia Experiment Raises Questions About Trust in Media

Synthesia created an interactive digital version of TechCrunch journalist Dominic-Madori Davis after capturing multiple images of her and recording two minutes of her voice. The result was not merely an image reciting written text, but an Avatar that listens to questions and converts them into text, then uses a language model to formulate a response and converts the answer into speech, while a video model animates the character’s facial features as it speaks.

The journalist chose to train the interactive version on a story she wrote about the reasons for the higher incidence of fraud among venture capital-backed startups compared with those that are not venture capital-backed. As a result, the twin was “deterministic”; that is, it answers only within the scope for which it was prepared and redirects questions outside that scope to the original story.

How Was the Digital Twin Built?

The Synthesia team needed a few days to create the models. The journalist received personal versions that read the texts she provided, and interactive versions that could listen and respond, with options either with or without glasses. The system uses Synthesia’s video and audio models, while also allowing users to select alternative models from Cartesia, ElevenLabs, Google, and OpenAI, in addition to options for hosting the twin on the client’s chosen cloud or with Synthesia.

The company places these capabilities into three main categories: a platform for creating and distributing video using traditional Avatars, the interactive Sessions platform for surveys and simulation exercises, and an API that allows audio and video models to be integrated with other services to build interactive Avatars or different products.

What Does the Experiment Reveal?

The journalist found that the voice was close to hers in the personal version, but her friends thought the resemblance in the interactive version was less convincing. Nevertheless, the presence was sufficient to produce an uncanny feeling, to the extent that her parents tried asking personal questions whose answers were known only to family members, without receiving a response because of the restrictions imposed by the training.

This result highlights an important difference between a narrowly controlled Avatar and a version powered by an open conversational model. The former is relatively predictable, but of limited use outside the material on which it was trained. The latter may appear more flexible, but it creates room for fabricated answers or behaviors that are difficult to control.

Why Does This News Matter?

The writer believes that the potential use in journalism is the most important question: Will audiences accept receiving news from a digital personality? Could an Avatar replace a journalist or allow chief executives to speak to a digital version of the journalist instead of the person herself? Her position is clear on one fundamental point: The essence of journalism is trust, and she does not believe this element can easily be delegated to artificial intelligence.

Outside media, the idea may be more appealing to companies and individuals; a digital version could answer questions while its owner is absent or assist with training and serving employees and customers. But the experiment does not prove that these models are ready to replace humans. Rather, it shows that controlling the scope of the answer and obtaining consent to use the voice and image remain central parts of their design.

The broader questions of use remain open: When does the audience know that it is speaking to an artificial version? Who bears responsibility for an incorrect answer? And what boundaries prevent the digital twin from turning from a practical interface into a personality that gives the user the impression of autonomy or knowledge it does not possess? These questions arise from the nature of the experiment itself, not from a promise that the technology will inevitably develop in any particular direction.

News source
TechCrunch AI
Open original source ↗
c
Author

certi.news Editorial Team

What you need to know

TechCrunch’s experiment with Synthesia demonstrates the possibility of creating an interactive digital twin that listens to questions and responds with voice and video within a defined knowledge scope. However, it highlights challenges involving trust, disclosure of the artificial nature of the interaction, and responsibility for incorrect answers, and it does not prove that these models are ready to replace humans.

  • Synthesia created an interactive digital version of journalist Dominic-Madori Davis using multiple images and a two-minute voice recording.
  • The twin converts questions into text, uses a language model to formulate answers, then converts them into speech and animates the character’s facial features while speaking.
  • The twin was trained on a single story, so its scope was limited; it redirected questions outside its subject to the original story.
  • Synthesia offers platforms for video and traditional Avatars, interactive sessions for simulations and polls, and an API for integrating voice and video with other services.
  • The result differed between a personal version that closely resembled the journalist’s voice and an interactive version whose visual and vocal resemblance was less convincing to her friends.
  • The experiment raises questions about public trust, disclosure that users are speaking with an artificial version, and the limits of delegating journalistic work to an Avatar.

FAQ

How does the digital twin answer questions?

It converts the question into text, uses a language model to formulate a response, converts the answer into speech, and animates the character’s facial features while speaking.

Can the twin answer any question?

No. It was trained on a single story and redirected questions outside its scope to the original story.

What are the technology’s main uses outside journalism?

Digital versions could help answer questions when their owner is unavailable, support training, or serve employees and customers.

Does the experiment prove that digital twins are ready to replace humans?

No. The article shows the importance of controlling the scope of answers and obtaining consent for the use of voice and images; it does not prove that the technology is ready to replace humans.

In the same category

You may also like

View all news