The Investigatory Powers Tribunal in the United Kingdom has allowed a significant part of Apple's legal challenge against a government request to access encrypted customer data to be heard publicly, after rejecting the Home Office's attempt to keep the matter confidential.
The tribunal ruled that the British government failed to prove that confirming the existence of the request would harm national security. Following this decision, the Home Office is now required to officially acknowledge that it issued Apple with what is known as a technical capability notice, a legal order that can compel companies to enable British security agencies to access user data even if it is protected by encryption.
Background of the Dispute and Secrecy Policy
The government's stance initially relied on a policy of neither confirming nor denying the issuance of such security notices. However, the tribunal concluded that frequent media leaks, including press reports and public discussions with US officials, had largely bypassed this policy to the extent that any observer of the dispute already knew in advance that Apple had received the technical notice. The tribunal considered the claim that official recognition poses a national security threat to be unrealistic.
This decision allows the proceedings led by Apple, alongside a separate challenge by human rights organizations such as Privacy International and Liberty, to proceed in open sessions. Apple filed its latest challenge last July following the issuance of a second technical notice, after the Home Office had previously agreed to withdraw an earlier request covering UK and US users following a dispute with the US government, shifting the replacement notice to focus exclusively on British users.
Impact of the Dispute on Advanced Data Protection Feature
This technical dispute has caused Apple to suspend the availability of the Advanced Data Protection feature for new users in the UK since February 2025. This feature provides end-to-end encryption for additional categories of cloud data, including device backups, photos, and notes, meaning Apple does not retain decryption keys.
British users who have not previously enabled the feature can no longer turn it on, while it remains active on accounts that used it previously without disabling it, as the company affirms it cannot deactivate it on behalf of users. Without this feature, cloud data categories are subject to standard protection where Apple retains decryption keys, allowing it to respond to valid legal requests, while services like iMessage and FaceTime remain fully encrypted alongside passwords and health data.