Privacy and Technology Policies

New U.S. Bill Expands Website-Blocking Orders to Include VPN Services

The EFF criticizes the American Copyright Protection Act, a bill that gives copyright holders a path to seek the blocking of foreign websites accused of piracy, while including VPN and DNS providers among the entities that could be required to implement the blocking. The organization believes the proposed procedural safeguards do not address the risks of blocking lawful websites or making the initial decision without the accused party present.

2026-10-02
4 min read
319 views
certi.news Editorial Team
New U.S. Bill Expands Website-Blocking Orders to Include VPN Services
The EFF criticizes the American Copyright Protection Act, a bill that gives copyright holders a path to seek the blocking of foreign websites accused of piracy, while including VPN and DNS providers among the entities that could be required to implement the blocking. The organization believes the proposed procedural safeguards do not address the risks of blocking lawful websites or making the initial decision without the accused party present.

U.S. Representative Darrell Issa introduced the American Copyright Protection Act (ACPA), known as H.R. 10364, to give copyright holders a new legal tool to seek to prevent users in the United States from accessing foreign websites whose operators are accused of copyright infringement.

The bill proposes a process in which the rights holder begins by asking a court to classify the website as a “foreign piracy site.” If the classification is issued, orders may be sought requiring internet service providers and DNS providers—and, explicitly this time, VPN providers as well—to take “commercially reasonable steps” to prevent U.S. users from accessing the site.

Expanding the Scope of Targeted Entities and Websites

According to an assessment by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), the ACPA goes beyond the Foreign Anti-Digital Piracy Act (FADPA), which was introduced the previous year and also opposed by the organization. FADPA excluded companies that provide VPN services only, as well as DNS providers that rely exclusively on encrypted DNS protocols, while the ACPA removes these protections and expressly includes VPNs among the service providers subject to blocking orders.

The bill also changes the definition of a website that can be classified as a piracy site. Instead of requiring that the site have “no significant commercial purpose or use” other than infringement, the ACPA requires only that other commercial purposes be “limited.” The EFF believes this change could expose sites with lawful commercial activities to blocking if their primary contribution is considered connected to copyright infringement.

Procedural Safeguards, but the Due-Process Problem Remains

The bill includes some safeguards, such as notifying service providers that may be subject to a blocking order and giving them an opportunity to respond, as well as requiring the court to consider potential harm to other websites and internet users. The court may also require the copyright holder to post a bond covering costs and damages if it is determined that the order was issued mistakenly.

Under certain circumstances, the text allows a claim for compensation after an erroneous blocking has occurred, and it also allows the website operator to seek cancellation of its classification. But the EFF believes these procedures do not address the core problem: the initial decision to classify a website can be made without its operator appearing before the court to defend itself. The judge may appoint an independent expert, or “special master,” to review the evidence, but the appointment is not mandatory, nor does the expert represent the accused website or the users affected by the blocking of information and speech.

Why Does This Matter?

The EFF draws on examples of blocking applications in other countries to warn of collateral harms. In Italy, 510 harmless websites that did not broadcast content were blocked, including a Catholic monastery and a telehealth platform, under the “Piracy Shield” program. In Spain, during soccer matches, a system blocked more than 550,000 domains, including sites belonging to Greenpeace and Harvard University.

The editorial interpretation here reflects the EFF’s position, not a settled legal fact: the bill did not become law during the period covered by the article, and the source does not establish how courts will interpret the “commercially reasonable steps” standard or the potential amount of damages. But the clear practical change is the direct inclusion of VPNs within the scope of blocking orders and the expansion of the definition of websites eligible for classification, increasing the importance of the debate for privacy-tool users and infrastructure providers alike.

The EFF concludes that adding procedural safeguards to a website-blocking system does not, in its view, change the nature of a system that would allow copyright holders to seek to block access to entire websites. It also recalls that Congress backed away more than a decade ago from the SOPA and PIPA bills after internet users objected to threats to blocking and an open internet.

News source
c
Author

certi.news Editorial Team

What you need to know

A proposed U.S. bill, the American Copyright Protection Act (H.R. 10364), would allow courts to be asked to block foreign websites whose operators are accused of copyright infringement, while including VPN and DNS providers among the entities that could be required to implement the blocking. The EFF criticizes the bill because it could result in lawful websites being blocked and because the initial designation could occur before the accused party has an opportunity to defend itself.

  • U.S. Representative Darrell Issa introduced the American Copyright Protection Act, known as ACPA, under the number H.R. 10364.
  • The bill would allow copyright holders to seek the designation of foreign websites as piracy sites and then request blocking orders from internet, DNS, and VPN providers.
  • The EFF believes that ACPA expands the scope of blockable websites by replacing the requirement that a site lack any significant commercial use with a standard based on the existence of other limited commercial uses.
  • The bill provides for notifying service providers and allowing them to respond, as well as the possibility of requiring a bond and awarding damages for wrongful blocking, but appointing an independent expert is not mandatory.
  • The EFF says the initial decision could be issued without the accused site operator being present and warns of collateral damage based on examples from Italy and Spain.
  • The bill has not become law according to the article, and how the commercially reasonable steps standard and the amount of damages will be interpreted remains unresolved.

FAQ

What is the American Copyright Protection Act?

It is a U.S. bill, numbered H.R. 10364, that would allow copyright holders to seek the designation of foreign websites as piracy sites and then request orders blocking access to them from the United States.

Does the bill include VPN providers?

Yes. The bill expressly includes VPN providers among the entities that could be required to take commercially reasonable steps to prevent access to designated websites.

What are the EFF's main objections?

The EFF says the bill could lead to lawful websites being blocked and that the initial designation could occur without the site operator being able to appear before the court and defend itself.

Has the bill become law?

No. The article states that the bill has not become law and that the effects of some of its provisions, such as the commercially reasonable steps standard, remain unresolved.

In the same category

You may also like

View all news